Transformation capital: A new investment logic for catalysing systems change

In its 2018 special report on the impacts of global warming of 1.5°C, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) called for the “rapid and unprecedented” transformation of the “socio-technical” systems that constitute modern human civilisation: Energy, agriculture, infrastructure, industry, and cities. This is a stark reminder that the world is not on track to avoid the most perilous impacts of a warming planet. What lies ahead is unparalleled in ambition and difficulty.

The way money flows and accumulates through the different parts of our economy will determine whether we can reduce greenhouse gas emissions and become climate-resilient in line with the Paris Agreement. However, today’s financial industry is ill-suited to fuelling the type of real-economy transformation the IPCC is calling for. This is also true for investment approaches branded as “sustainable finance” such as environmental, social and governance (ESG), triple bottom line investing (TBLI), socially responsible investing (SRI), or impact investing.

This is why we invited more than 50 systems thinkers, innovation practitioners, investment professionals, and creative voices during this month’s first-ever London Climate Action Week to design a new investment logic capable of catalysing systems transformation. The workshop helped us refine our understanding of the limitations of present-day capital markets and sharpen the contours around the building blocks of a systems-transformative investment logic.

The key to transformative investing is to recognise that the world at large—and the socio-technical systems nestled within it—behaves as a complex adaptive system. Such a system is constantly evolving but impossible to predict, and it therefore often behaves in a non-linear fashion.

In viewing the world through this lens, it becomes apparent that the finance industry’s single asset paradigm—one stock, one bond or one project—will never be able to unleash transformative effects. A more promising approach is to construct portfolios for strategic synergies, selecting individual assets not based on their individual merit but based on how they reinforce the portfolio’s potential to unlock transformative dynamics.

Take the electrification of transportation. Investors usually take bets on single investment propositions—an electric vehicle start-up, a manufacturer of charging infrastructure, a developer of fleet management software, or an installer of household-level power generation and storage systems.

By taking a systems approach and investing in all stages of the electric transportation value chain—for instance, through the strategic blending of different instruments and asset classes—investors can significantly increase the likelihood that a market for electric transportation will emerge. All that is needed is for asset owners and managers to abandon their siloed mindsets and structures, eliminating categorisation where possible.

However, economies are not just made up of technologies and businesses but also of people and institutions. To catalyse systems transformation, it is necessary to engage all levers of change in the system, including policy and regulatory frameworks, social norms and behaviours, skills and capabilities, individual and collective narratives, and production and consumption paradigms. Many of these interventions are non-investable under the traditional investment logic—but they create value for society at large. So systemic investors should align themselves deeply with actors interested in promoting public goods, such as governments, philanthropists, and multilateral institutions.

That still leaves the question of what to spend money on. Not all interventions in a system—whether investable or not—have the same potential to unleash transformative effects. This is why it is critical to identify sensitive intervention points—those places in the system where a relatively small change can trigger outsize effects and where non-linear feedbacks can act as amplifiers. Often, it will not be apparent where to act first, so the initial positions will represent a hypothesis. Investors must therefore be competent in observing the system and making sense of what emerges within it so that they can dynamically allocate capital to where the desired transition dynamics take hold.

Systemic investing relies on a multitude of additional concepts and capabilities. It requires that we map systems, hypothesise transition pathways, and design transformation strategies. It also means that we need to re-conceptualise risk and return, away from the self-referential paradigm of capital accumulation toward a coupling with the success and uncertainties of catalysing transformational dynamics. We can operationalise these concepts through new business models, adapted financial instruments, and innovative public-private investment partnerships.

EIT Climate-KIC has set out to develop and test these elements with its community of innovators. We believe that deploying capital for the transformative change that the IPCC is calling for requires that we re-imagine the role of capital in promoting a prosperous, sustainable, and inclusive society. This does not imply overthrowing capitalism, revolutionising the monetary system, or disregarding the interests and fiduciary obligations of asset owners. Much can be achieved by simply deploying capital in a smarter way and on a bigger playing field. If you are a challenge owner, innovation practitioner, and investment professional keen to address the most pressing and tangible problems of our time, we are keen to hear from you.

This article first appeared in Environmental Finance.

 
Location
Related Goal
Goal 10: Mainstream climate in financial markets
Articles you may be interested in
In Detail
Exploring frontiers in sustainability: Bringing futures literacy to financia...

As part of EIT Climate-KIC’s Long-termism Deep Demonstration, Riyong Kim, Director of Decision Metrics and Finance at EIT Climate-KIC, has co-authored a new report,...

Exploring frontiers in sustainability: Bringing futures literacy to financial services in Ireland and France
Opinion
Long democracies
Dark Matter
Long democracies
Opinion
Long financing in a volatile world
Dark Matter
Long financing in a volatile world
Opinion
Long welfare
Dark Matter
Long welfare
Opinion
Abstracted to entangled organisation
Dark Matter
Abstracted to entangled organisation
Opinion
Persistent things
Dark Matter
Persistent things
Opinion
Persistent selves
Dark Matter
Persistent selves
Opinion
Futures in long-termism
Dark Matter
Futures in long-termism
In our community
Strengthening community ties and supporting each other through the COVID-19 ...
Strengthening community ties and supporting each other through the COVID-19 crisis
Opinion
The Corona canvas: How to deal with the crisis as a founder
Marc Mogalle & Anje Kluth Business Buddies & EIT Climate-KIC
The Corona canvas: How to deal with the crisis as a founder
In The News
Lilium completes funding round worth over €224 million

EIT Climate-KIC supported Lilium, a Munich-based aviation company developing...

Lilium completes funding round worth over €224 million
In The News
TWAICE raises €11 million series A to power internationalisation efforts and...

EIT Climate-KIC supported TWAICE, a Munich-based battery specialist, has...

TWAICE raises €11 million series A to power internationalisation efforts and scaling
In our community
Madrid: A city turning eco-fictions into eco-futures through systems innovat...
Madrid: A city turning eco-fictions into eco-futures through systems innovation
In The News
EIT Community shines on Forbes 30 under 30 Europe list

Eight EIT Climate-KIC innovators are featured in the prestigious...

EIT Community shines on Forbes 30 under 30 Europe list
Opinion
Trees as infrastructure: Part two
Dark Matter
Trees as infrastructure: Part two
Opinion
Trees as infrastructure: Part one
Dark Matter
Trees as infrastructure: Part one
Opinion
Could COVID-19 usher in massive systemic change?
EIT Climate-KIC Italy
Could COVID-19 usher in massive systemic change?
Opinion
Working during corona lockdown: EIT Climate-KIC Italy sets an example
EIT Climate-KIC Italy
Working during corona lockdown: EIT Climate-KIC Italy sets an example
Innovation Spotlight
How to improve building energy performance without up-front capital

Air-conditioning equipment, office furniture, lighting systems and even floor coverings are being leased, so why can’t a...

How to improve building energy performance without up-front capital
In The News
EU Taxonomy shows the way to net zero by 2050

The Technical Expert Group (TEG) on Sustainable Finance has...

EU Taxonomy shows the way to net zero by 2050
In The News
Regine Kreitz new EIT Climate-KIC Director of Marketing and Communications

Regine Kreitz will join EIT Climate-KIC, the European Union’s...

Regine Kreitz new EIT Climate-KIC Director of Marketing and Communications
In The News
KICs tackling water scarcity in Southern Europe

How EIT and KICs are working to address one...

KICs tackling water scarcity in Southern Europe
In The News
EIT Climate-KIC and partners launch Massive Open Online Course on e-waste

EIT Climate-KIC, together with its partners the UN, the...

EIT Climate-KIC and partners launch Massive Open Online Course on e-waste
In The News
Five EIT Climate-KIC innovators featured in Global Cleantech 100

Five EIT Climate-KIC supported innovative ventures included in the...

Five EIT Climate-KIC innovators featured in Global Cleantech 100
In The News
The journey to zero-emissions transport – part three

The transport sector already accounts for a quarter of...

The journey to zero-emissions transport – part three
In The News
The journey to zero-emissions transport – part two

The transport sector already accounts for a quarter of...

The journey to zero-emissions transport – part two
In The News
The journey to zero-emissions transport – part one

The transport sector already accounts for a quarter of...

The journey to zero-emissions transport – part one
In The News
Malaysia and Estonia win Climathon Global Awards at ChangeNOW summit

The city of Penang, Malaysia, and a team of...

Malaysia and Estonia win Climathon Global Awards at ChangeNOW summit
Opinion
Redesigning venture capital (part III): A hypothesis
Dominic Hofstetter Transformation Capital, EIT Climate-KIC
Redesigning venture capital (part III): A hypothesis
Opinion
The Long Time
Beatrice Pembroke & Ella Saltmarshe Co-founders, The Long Time Project
The Long Time