Triggering a critical mass of sustainable investment: How can Europe do it?

Written by Kirsten Dunlop, CEO, EIT Climate-KIC. Originally published in EurActiv

The European Commission’s HLEG Working Group on Sustainable Finance released its long-awaited final report on 31 January. More than two years after the Paris Agreement and implementation of the Sustainable Development Goals, Europe looks ready to put finance to task, leveraging its structural potential in helping a green economy bloom.

The report proposals – including a taxonomy to provide market clarity on what ‘sustainable’ is; clarification of investor duties in considering sustainability in investment decisions; improvement in disclosure; and an EU-wide label for green investment funds – have been broadly welcomed in banking and policymaking circles.

The proposals aim to get to the heart of finance and change behaviour by targeting the incentives that matter to investors like capital requirements and investment mandates. But will these proposals drive change in finance sufficient to meet the complexity of decarbonisation projects and the scale of transformations needed to stay on track with current climate targets and a 2ºC pathway?

Europe has done well at stimulating renewable energy infrastructure, and market opportunities that are vertical and aligned with traditional business perspectives seeking growth and return on investment. This model, however, does not incentivise financial flows to projects and actions vital to a low carbon development path, for example in retrofitting Europe’s building stock or integrated energy-mobility-dwelling models.

Unlike renewable energy, transport and deep retrofit require engagement with myriad stakeholders with an array of interests. Such a heterogeneous landscape may deter investments. The next wave of climate innovation will be based on the internet of things, including distributed ledgers and digital intelligence, resulting in the increased selling of services rather than products and greater transparency in value chains.

To encourage investment in such projects, public finance has a responsibility to explore how best to take the first loss risk and develop a track record to incentivise private sector investors to manage the associated risks.

Effective business models that manage to blend concessional finance with private finance and can address the demands of the multiple stakeholders involved are desperately needed.

So, how can traditional investment appetite be changed? The answer lies in diversity and in the introduction of a resilience and renewal logic to the strategic allocation of capital – capital directed at ‘hedging’ or rather ‘underwriting’ business model renewal in the face of disruptive change. Working with a spectrum of risk and opportunity appetites, a range of financial partners, sectoral specialisms and techniques and a portfolio approach designed to learn can help create an ecosystem of finance partners working in a more patient, considered and democratised way.

This ecosystem might include national banks, philanthropic funders, impact investors, local credit unions or crowdfunding mechanisms, convened together with mainstream finance players. Creating a platform for this financial co-creation of investment solutions could help trigger a breakthrough in the critical mass of sustainable investments across Europe.

One less discussed proposal in the HLEG report that supports this is a proposal to create ‘Sustainable Infrastructure Europe’. This capacity building hub would facilitate a transfer of lessons learned and insights from across the European, national and local level to help develop and implement projects as testbeds for change contract effectively with private sources of capital and give advice on how to reduce uncertainty in a patchwork of regulatory environments.

This is something that can be built on. To meet the EU’s broader environmental and sustainability goals, the bottlenecks constraining investment in sustainable infrastructure on both the demand and supply side must be addressed.

Some of these bottlenecks on the supply side will be generic to the targeted industrial activities, while others may be related to specific environments where activities occur. Different regions will have a varying institutional capacity to absorb finance.

As the report authors emphasise, access to capital is not so pressing as project development capacity. Many large-scale private funds are ready and willing to invest but are unable to identify attractive investment opportunities, not least because of poor enabling environments.

Such a body must be a platform where a diverse finance ecosystem can co-develop projects, share funding information, best practices and methodologies, and make vital connections between project demand and supply.

This will be crucial to the understanding of how to generate an enabling environment – institutional capacity, labour market skills, and policy frameworks – as well as providing the financial sector with better tools for assessing climate-related risks and for investing in strategic innovation options capable of generating renewal and economically viable transformation.

 

Climate-KIC’s Decision Metrics and Finance team works with our network of partners to develop the metrics and financial mechanisms to redirect and mobilise the finance needed to quickly scale up climate action.

Find out more

 
Location
Belgium
Articles you may be interested in
In The News
Europe’s moment to lead on green financial centres

Pascal Donohue,  Minister for Finance and Stephen Nolan, Sustainable...

Europe’s moment to lead on green financial centres
Opinion
Rewiring finance through climate innovation
Kirsten Dunlop Chief Executive Officer, EIT Climate-KIC
Rewiring finance through climate innovation
In our community
Interview with Karim Tarraf, CEO, Hawa Dawa
Interview with Karim Tarraf, CEO, Hawa Dawa
In our community
Interview with Asger Hansen, CEO, Havsans IVS
Interview with Asger Hansen, CEO, Havsans IVS
Innovation Spotlight
Landscape Finance Lab: Key partnerships with major corporations to drive sus...

In Innovation Spotlight, we explore some of the most promising innovations from around our community. This week,...

Landscape Finance Lab: Key partnerships with major corporations to drive sustainable land use
In The News
Solar Impulse network joins forces with EIT Climate-KIC to accelerate innovati...

EIT Climate-KIC, Europe’s main climate innovation initiative has joined...

Solar Impulse network joins forces with EIT Climate-KIC to accelerate innovation
Opinion
Consumers play a decisive role in the shift towards a circular economy
Ulrike Linnig Innovation Lead, Germany, EIT Climate-KIC
Consumers play a decisive role in the shift towards a circular economy
In The News
Updated Investor Marketplace aims to scale green funding with networks effects

Before the recent launch of EIT Climate-KIC’s new Investor...

Updated Investor Marketplace aims to scale green funding with networks effects
In The News
World’s leading finance innovators to outline new mission for finance at Eur...

‘Mission Finance’ – the mission critical opportunities for collaboration...

World’s leading finance innovators to outline new mission for finance at Europe’s top climate innovation summit
Innovation Spotlight
CRAMS’ comprehensive climate datasets enable financial institutions to...

In Innovation Spotlight, we explore some of the most promising innovations from around our community. This week,...

CRAMS’ comprehensive climate datasets enable financial institutions to satisfy TCFD recommendations
In our community
Interview with Charlotte Thiery, Project Manager, InclusivEV
Interview with Charlotte Thiery, Project Manager, InclusivEV
In The News
UN sustainable finance centres network establishes base in Dublin, home of thi...

A United Nations programme, supported by EIT Climate-KIC, which...

UN sustainable finance centres network establishes base in Dublin, home of this year’s Climate Innovation Summit
In The News
EIT Climate-KIC-supported Climeworks raises €27 million to commercialise CO2...

Climeworks AG, the world leader in capturing CO2 from...

EIT Climate-KIC-supported Climeworks raises €27 million to commercialise CO2 removal technology
Opinion
Harvesting opportunities for health, wealth and climate stability in regenerative agriculture
Daniel Zimmer Daniel Zimmer, Director Sustainable Land Use, EIT Climate-KIC
Harvesting opportunities for health, wealth and climate stability in regenerative agriculture
In Detail
How can digitalisation unlock the circular economy’s potential?

With the global population rapidly increasing, it’s become essential to review our current system to adapt to the growing demand for basic goods and...

How can digitalisation unlock the circular economy’s potential?
In The News
Quantis and EIT Climate-KIC to develop spatial lifecycle analysis tool for sus...

Swiss sustainability consultancy Quantis has launched a two-year project, supported...

Quantis and EIT Climate-KIC to develop spatial lifecycle analysis tool for sustainable supply chains
In The News
Naked Energy secures funding to launch Virtu, the world’s most efficient...

Naked Energy has successfully closed its funding round at...

Naked Energy secures funding to launch Virtu, the world’s most efficient hybrid solar panel
Innovation Spotlight
How hemp can catalyse a cross-industry green shift

In Innovation Spotlight, we explore some of the most promising innovations from around our community. This week,...

How hemp can catalyse a cross-industry green shift
In The News
City of Bologna set to scale up local carbon market after successful EIT Clima...

The development of local carbon markets can catapult cities...

City of Bologna set to scale up local carbon market after successful EIT Climate-KIC pilot
In Detail
Increasing the resilience and sustainability of European forests

What are the climate challenges faced by European temperate forests? What is their potential for climate mitigation, directly, and by relieving commercial pressures on...

Increasing the resilience and sustainability of European forests
In our community
Interview with Christopher Lee, CEO, Climate-KIC Australia
Interview with Christopher Lee, CEO, Climate-KIC Australia
In The News
Zero-water shampoo start-up wins Smart Agrifood Summit award

A biodegradable cosmetics start-up using agricultural waste to make...

Zero-water shampoo start-up wins Smart Agrifood Summit award
In our community
Marie Dittmann, creator of Future of Farming MOOC
Marie Dittmann, creator of Future of Farming MOOC
In The News
Hyperloop pioneers welcome a new era in high-speed transportation with industr...

Leading hyperloop companies TransPod (from Canada), Hardt Hyperloop (from...

Hyperloop pioneers welcome a new era in high-speed transportation with industry-first international alliance
In our community
We’re in innovation, right? So why interact in such traditional ways?
Dr Michelle Zucker EIT Climate-KIC Community Management Lead
We’re in innovation, right? So why interact in such traditional ways?
Innovation Spotlight
How mushroom mycelia are transforming industrial materials

In Innovation Spotlight, we explore some of the most promising innovations from around our community. This week,...

How mushroom mycelia are transforming industrial materials
In The News
EIT Climate-KIC’s Carbon Delta takes on climate disclosures project with...

Carbon Delta, the climate risk analysis company supported by...

EIT Climate-KIC’s Carbon Delta takes on climate disclosures project with the UN
In our community
Interview with Prof. Jacopo Gaspari of EIT Climate-KIC’s PhD Catapult
Interview with Prof. Jacopo Gaspari of EIT Climate-KIC’s PhD Catapult
In The News
Introducing the Innovation Review

EIT Climate-KIC this week launches Innovation Review — a...

Introducing the Innovation Review
Opinion
We need mandatory due diligence on investments, says EU rapporteur
Molly Scott Cato MEP for the South West of England and Gibraltar; Green Party speaker on Brexit and on Finance
We need mandatory due diligence on investments, says EU rapporteur