Reframing perspectives on climate change

Where should investors be putting their money to make a real impact when it comes to climate change? And how should businesses react? Shifting the perspective from risk to opportunity can create an unexpected leverage point that could present the answer.

The plenary session on the second day of the Climate Innovation Summit in Dublin put climate change impact at the heart of financial discussions. Dennis Pamlin, Senior Advisor at Research Institutes Sweden (RISE), and Andrew Parry, Head of Sustainable Investment at Hermes Investment Management shared their forward-looking perspectives on how to reframe our current understanding of climate change, and how to foster discourse that speaks the language of investors.

Facilitated by EIT Climate-KIC advisor to the EU Sustainable Finance Technical Expert Group Sandrine Dixson-Declève, the speakers set the frame by emphasising how we tend to treat climate change as an environmental issue; as a risk matter on the side, as nothing more than CSR:

“It gets grouped into the weakest department of the company and comes in as the last part of discussion, often grouped together with other environmental issues. But it’s not. Climate change is an existential threat, yet 99 per cent of society do not frame it as such,” Dennis Pamlin said.

Andrew Parry followed up on this statement by linking it to an investment perspective:

“We need to rethink impact to encourage the creation of impact-enabled business models. Not as a linear way of solving problems but by putting impact at the heart of business models. Everyone talks about ESG but that is so 1990s. You must instead start to think about sustainability. It is forward-looking. Don’t think about the portfolio but rather about the components of the portfolio

He continued: “For people coming into the field, there are a lot of acronyms and differing opinions. It’s messy and complicated. This is challenging for finance and investment-orientated people who are used to looking at an index.”

Both speakers agreed that the current climate change benchmark tends to be rooted in the structure of the past:

“The need for reduced emissions is often based on an assumption that the current system is the one we should have. We talk about how we can reduce emissions and how to set reduction-based emission targets in the existing system. Often that does not help us create the tomorrow that we want. Most current frameworks are based on yesterday’s world, for instance, reporting systems. We are still asking the big polluters to take small steps,” Pamlin explained.

In the context of pension fund investments and the challenges of sustainability versus current structure, Andrew Parry shared the following perspective:

“They blame it on QE. It is hard for pension funds to integrate sustainable investments because they have to reach their 4 per cent inflation rate. Why are pension funds not doing more? Because they are constrained by the current structures in place, so they have to make a minimum return.”

By reframing our current narrative about climate change and situating it in a context of opportunity rather than risk, it can become something that increases human well-being rather than coming at the expense of it.

“Climate change is perceived as stopping something, not creating it. But there has been a dramatic change in costs for key environmental technologies and new transparency tools are now possible. The Overton window is moving very fast. Being rational is being stupid, it is being short-sighted and looking back,” said Pamlin.

So how do we advance the discussion and translate words into action? And how do we incorporate the business perspective?

“We need to reframe the question about how we interact with companies. If you frame sustainability and climate change as fear, you lose them. It must be framed in terms of how we make money. SDGs are a way of reframing the conversation. Make it context-based. Frame it in terms of a better way to invest and disclose,” said Parry.

Pamlin followed up with his perspective:

“We must be much bolder and reach out to those who have not been part of the discussion before. There is no silver bullet to this. We must bring in a broader focus and let the ideas flourish. We should have at least five scenarios that are possible, not just one to bring us forward. It should be on the front page, in the legal pages and on the finance pages.”

In conclusion, both speakers shared their final remarks on how to keep on progressing:

“Doing more with less will only create incremental solutions. We must rethink the entire process. Everyone is a part of this transition, all hands on deck, we need that. Many of the people that are good at talking are not necessarily good at action”, said Pamlin.

“My biggest fear about a lot of the greatest things we are doing in Europe is the sustainability arbitrage. Many look at this with a short-term lens, a Milton Friedman approach. We have to make sure that we carry the voice of the world to change the system. We cannot do this in isolation,” said Parry.

With the carbon costs of travel in mind, Climate Innovation Summit session summaries are available online for those who cannot attend—and for review for those present. These summaries aim to extract the key debates, dialogues, and learnings from each #MissionFinance session.

 
Location
Ireland
Related Goal
Goal 12: Foster bankable green assets in cities
Articles you may be interested in
In Detail
Municipality-led circular economy case studies from EIT Climate-KIC and part...

How can cities create prosperity for expanding populations whose rates of consumption are increasing, while strengthening the systemic change that supports waste and resource management?...

Municipality-led circular economy case studies from EIT Climate-KIC and partners
In Detail
Transformative change through innovation: An analysis of the role of innovat...

One of the areas with significant potential to reduce carbon emissions is the energy sector, including the transition away from coal. It is, and...

Transformative change through innovation: An analysis of the role of innovation in five transition regions
In The News
COP24 report: The vital role of land use in climate mitigation

With the carbon costs of travel in mind, key...

COP24 report: The vital role of land use in climate mitigation
In The News
COP24: Distributed ledger technology could help enact Paris Agreement

With the carbon costs of travel in mind, key...

COP24: Distributed ledger technology could help enact Paris Agreement
Opinion
System innovation is needed to help regions shift to a low-carbon economy
System innovation is needed to help regions shift to a low-carbon economy
In The News
COP24: Social innovation to drive just transition of coal regions

With the carbon costs of travel in mind, key...

COP24: Social innovation to drive just transition of coal regions
In Detail
DLT for climate action assessment

DOWNLOAD THE REPORT Over the past decade, we’ve witnessed a myriad of milestones that have put the vision of a prosperous, climate-resilient society on...

DLT for climate action assessment
In The News
EIT Climate-KIC’s ConnectedClusters launches at EUROCITIES

EIT Climate-KIC’s ConnectedClusters project—which aims to accelerate innovation clusters...

EIT Climate-KIC’s ConnectedClusters launches at EUROCITIES
Opinion
St. Patrick is on a Mission – #MissionFinance 1.5 C
Sandra Vlašić, Partnerships, Resources and Stories Terra Hub
St. Patrick is on a Mission – #MissionFinance 1.5 C
In our community
EIT Climate-KIC to showcase its top 30 cleantech startups during Slush 2018
EIT Climate-KIC to showcase its top 30 cleantech startups during Slush 2018
In The News
How to unlock the finance needed for integrated landscape approaches

Why integrated landscape approaches matter and how to unlock...

How to unlock the finance needed for integrated landscape approaches
In The News
Regional Innovation Scheme start-ups showcase cleantech achievements supported...

Last month (October 2018) in Vienna, Austria, 32 start-ups...

Regional Innovation Scheme start-ups showcase cleantech achievements supported by EIT Climate-KIC
In The News
City Finance Lab explores new advisory services to catalyse investment in sust...

With the carbon costs of travel in mind, Climate...

City Finance Lab explores new advisory services to catalyse investment in sustainable cities
In The News
EIT Climate-KIC responds to consultation on Long-Term Strategy for EU GHG emis...

As an active member of the community working to...

EIT Climate-KIC responds to consultation on Long-Term Strategy for EU GHG emissions reduction
Opinion
Distributed ledger technologies are here to stay
Dr. Harald Rauter Regional Innovation Lead, Climate-KIC
Distributed ledger technologies are here to stay
In The News
Search for 100 1.5C-compatible investments launched

The EU-backed Mission Innovation initiative has launched a framework...

Search for 100 1.5C-compatible investments launched
In The News
Can self-reporting be effective for investors?

Most climate and ESG data is self-reported – can...

Can self-reporting be effective for investors?
In The News
Risky business: Why 1.5C-aligned strategies are key to preserving capital

Decision-makers with responsibility for capital need to make bold,...

Risky business: Why 1.5C-aligned strategies are key to preserving capital
In The News
No alternative: Making sustainable infrastructure the only option

Only a fraction of global climate finance is reaching...

No alternative: Making sustainable infrastructure the only option
In The News
Could ambitious financial regulation be a key driver of climate action?

With the carbon costs of travel in mind, Climate...

Could ambitious financial regulation be a key driver of climate action?
In The News
Bridging the climate adaptation investment gap

Financing climate adaptation took centre-stage at Day 2 of...

Bridging the climate adaptation investment gap
In Detail
Techno-economic assessment and life cycle assessment guidelines for CO2 util...

CO2 utilisation technologies, also known as carbon capture and utilisation (CCU) or CO2 re-use, capture CO2 and convert it into new products or services....

Techno-economic assessment and life cycle assessment guidelines for CO2 utilisation
In The News
Re-Industrialise launches at the European Week of Cities and Regions

EIT Climate-KIC and partners recently launched the Re-Industrialise programme,...

Re-Industrialise launches at the European Week of Cities and Regions
In Detail
Reframing our current approach to urban transformations

EIT Climate-KIC gathered the outputs and lessons-learned from an urban transformations community workshop in Malaga, which saw more than 100 city leaders and teams...

Reframing our current approach to urban transformations
Opinion
Only 20 companies in the world provide 100 per cent greenhouse gas emissions disclosure – Are ...
Only 20 companies in the world provide 100 per cent greenhouse gas emissions disclosure – Are investors in the dark on climate risks?
In The News
Gaining a better understanding of climate risk

The roadblocks that stand in the way of companies...

Gaining a better understanding of climate risk
In The News
The power of persuasion: Great Debate changes audience’s mind on self-re...

With the carbon costs of travel in mind, Climate...

The power of persuasion: Great Debate changes audience’s mind on self-reporting
In The News
A masterclass on climate-related financial disclosure

If we want to keep on track with the...

A masterclass on climate-related financial disclosure
In The News
Transforming financial sector’s core value system may be essential to 1.5C

With the carbon costs of travel in mind, Climate...

Transforming financial sector’s core value system may be essential to 1.5C
In The News
Curbing carbon emissions in company value chains

Most of the world’s largest companies account and report...

Curbing carbon emissions in company value chains