The green bonds market needs to maintain integrity while growing

With more and more companies recognising and acting on the risk from climate change in their portfolios, they are beginning to look for alternative assets, which often don’t exist at sufficient scale.

The emerging green bonds market provides a big opportunity and needs to grow, but maintaining its environmental integrity is crucial. This was my takeaway from last week’s World Bank conference in Barcelona, Innovate4Climate, a global dialogue of government, multi-laterals, business, banking and finance leaders focused on shaping the next generation of climate finance and policy instruments.

The state of climate finance

Following the Paris Agreement, the money spent by government on climate change mitigation and adaptation projects — climate finance — has grown in importance and in awareness. Most importantly though, the private sector has started to embrace the topic.

While we can be positive that the dynamics are picking up, we’ve still got a long long way to go. As the motto of the conference went, we need to “shift and unlock the trillions”, or in other words, turn all of our financial flows green.

Not enough alternative assets

I think the dynamics are promising, but how you reach the mainstream remains a challenge. It’s one thing to understand what the risks in your portfolio are, trying to shift your investment, but the very crucial part is having enough new activity, enough new investment opportunities in the low-carbon resilience space.

The green bonds market is one opportunity that everybody’s enthusiastic about, because it’s a new kind of asset class at a level that is relevant to some of the big investors. However, demand completely outstrips supply in that space. The question is: how we can grow that market and mobilise other new assets?

The green bonds market

At Innovate4Climate, I moderated a side event on the topic. We had participation from a broad range of people  in the field — Patrick Bürgi from Southpole Group; Igor Shishlov from I4CE, a think-tank on climate economics; Lisa Wong from Affirmative Investment Management, a dedicated green and impact bond fund management company, and Björn Bergstrand from Kommunivest, a public financial institution with a large track record in issuing green bonds.

Everybody agreed that we need to both ensure the future growth of this market and that increasing its environmental integrity is crucial. There was also agreement that it is important to differentiate between defining what is green at the outset of including projects in a green bond and then reporting on the green performance of the underlying assets over time.

There was disagreement, however, on how to get there.

Difference of opinion

Some were in favour of stricter and more generally applicable standards, and drew on experiences from the early and contested years of the carbon markets and worried about crises in the market stemming from less green projects being labelled as green. Clearer and widely acceptable standards would reduce complexity and remove the search costs on the investor side.

Others stressed that leading market players will continue to innovate and drive standards higher (with others adopting) while a top-down standard applicable to all kinds of projects would reduce the willingness to go beyond these. Investors would, therefore, not engage more with the actual investments and underlying assets, which was seen as a clear plus.

Furthermore, there was a fear that introducing onerous additional requirements at this time would create too much of a financial burden to green bond issuers reducing the much-needed dynamics on the supply side.

The truth, as always, probably lies in the middle – increasing transparency and standardisation where possible while not dis-incentivising innovation and differentiation, and keeping transaction costs low. One idea coming from the audience in this regard was to think about how to deal with different shades of green and explore development of an acceptable rating.

Climate-KIC has kicked-off an exploratory project with Southpole Group, its partner, to survey the market with respect to environmental integrity. This work will include the development of a set of options for further strengthening the growth and integrity of the market, resulting in recommendations and proposed actor coalitions to take this forward.

Blockchain

Another topic that came up at Innovate4Climate was blockchain — an even more nascent market. Discussion was around how can make a difference in transparency and reduce transaction costs, enabling the market to simplify.

Ranging from a keynote by Alex Tapscott, co-author of one of the leading books in the space, and side events, it was clear that the market is keen to explore the application options of this promising technology both on the policy and the private sector side.

 

 
Location
Articles you may be interested in
In The News
EIT Climate-KIC responds to consultation on Long-Term Strategy for EU GHG emis...

As an active member of the community working to...

EIT Climate-KIC responds to consultation on Long-Term Strategy for EU GHG emissions reduction
Opinion
Distributed ledger technologies are here to stay
Dr. Harald Rauter Regional Innovation Lead, Climate-KIC
Distributed ledger technologies are here to stay
In The News
Search for 100 1.5C-compatible investments launched

The EU-backed Mission Innovation initiative has launched a framework...

Search for 100 1.5C-compatible investments launched
In The News
Debate: Can self-reporting be effective for investors?

Most climate and ESG data is self-reported – can...

Debate: Can self-reporting be effective for investors?
In The News
Risky business: Why 1.5C-aligned strategies are key to preserving capital

Decision-makers with responsibility for capital need to make bold,...

Risky business: Why 1.5C-aligned strategies are key to preserving capital
In The News
No alternative: Making sustainable infrastructure the only option

Only a fraction of global climate finance is reaching...

No alternative: Making sustainable infrastructure the only option
In The News
We’ve seen it with GDPR and data protection—could ambitious financial ...

With the carbon costs of travel in mind, Climate...

We’ve seen it with GDPR and data protection—could ambitious financial regulation be a key driver of climate action?
In The News
Bridging the climate adaptation investment gap

Financing climate adaptation took centre-stage at Day 2 of...

Bridging the climate adaptation investment gap
In Detail
Techno-economic assessment and life cycle assessment guidelines for CO2 util...

CO2 utilisation technologies, also known as carbon capture and utilisation (CCU) or CO2 re-use, capture CO2 and convert it into new products or services....

Techno-economic assessment and life cycle assessment guidelines for CO2 utilisation
In The News
Re-Industrialise launches at the European Week of Cities and Regions

EIT Climate-KIC and partners recently launched the Re-Industrialise programme,...

Re-Industrialise launches at the European Week of Cities and Regions
In Detail
Reframing our current approach to urban transformations

EIT Climate-KIC gathered the outputs and lessons-learned from an urban transformations community workshop in Malaga, which saw more than 100 city leaders and teams...

Reframing our current approach to urban transformations
Opinion
Reframing perspectives on climate change
Reframing perspectives on climate change
Opinion
Only 20 companies in the world provide 100 per cent greenhouse gas emissions disclosure – Are ...
Only 20 companies in the world provide 100 per cent greenhouse gas emissions disclosure – Are investors in the dark on climate risks?
In The News
Gaining a better understanding of climate risk

The roadblocks that stand in the way of companies...

Gaining a better understanding of climate risk
In The News
The power of persuasion: Great Debate changes audience’s mind on self-re...

With the carbon costs of travel in mind, Climate...

The power of persuasion: Great Debate changes audience’s mind on self-reporting
In The News
Climate Innovation Summit: a masterclass on climate-related financial disclosu...

If we want to keep on track with the...

Climate Innovation Summit: a masterclass on climate-related financial disclosure
In The News
Transforming financial sector’s core value system may be essential to 1.5C

With the carbon costs of travel in mind, Climate...

Transforming financial sector’s core value system may be essential to 1.5C
In The News
Curbing carbon emissions in company value chains

Most of the world’s largest companies account and report...

Curbing carbon emissions in company value chains
In The News
One hundred 1.5C compatible investments by 2030

New investor framework launched today at European Climate Innovation...

One hundred 1.5C compatible investments by 2030
In The News
‘Fearless Girl’ appears at EIT Climate-KIC’s Climate Innovation Summit

Fearless Girl—the famous bronze statue erected in Lower Manhattan...

‘Fearless Girl’ appears at EIT Climate-KIC’s Climate Innovation Summit
In our community
Interview with Leeor Groen, Venture Manager, Blockchain Valley Ventures
Interview with Leeor Groen, Venture Manager, Blockchain Valley Ventures
In The News
EIT Climate-KIC partners with South Pole for Climate Innovation Summit carbon ...

EIT Climate-KIC’s Climate Innovation Summit (CIS) will feature a...

EIT Climate-KIC partners with South Pole for Climate Innovation Summit carbon offsetting programme
In The News
Financing tomorrow’s new normal today

First published in Environmental Finance as part of a joint...

Financing tomorrow’s new normal today
In The News
Climathon 2018 will be the biggest global climate hackathon in history

Over 100 cities from around the world will join...

Climathon 2018 will be the biggest global climate hackathon in history
Opinion
How can we mainstream major climate risks into financial reporting?
Hanna Värttö Senior Consultant, South Pole Group
How can we mainstream major climate risks into financial reporting?
In The News
EIT Climate-KIC emphasises need for climate focus in cohesion policy at Europe...

EIT Climate-KIC was among the urban planners, municipalities, policy...

EIT Climate-KIC emphasises need for climate focus in cohesion policy at European Week of Cities and Regions
In The News
EIT Climate-KIC’s secrets for successfully running accelerators revealed...

EIT Climate-KIC has been featured in “Accelerate This!”, a...

EIT Climate-KIC’s secrets for successfully running accelerators revealed in “Accelerate This!”
Opinion
Harvesting the intelligence of photosynthetic microalgae to de-carbonise future cities
Marco Poletto Co-founder and Director, ecoLogicStudio
Harvesting the intelligence of photosynthetic microalgae to de-carbonise future cities
In our community
Interview with Mariana Mazzucato, Professor, Economics of Innovation and Pub...
Interview with Mariana Mazzucato, Professor, Economics of Innovation and Public Value, UCL
In The News
Why we invest in sustainable start-ups

A growing number of investors recognise the value in...

Why we invest in sustainable start-ups