The power of persuasion: Great Debate changes audience’s mind on self-reporting

With the carbon costs of travel in mind, Climate Innovation Summit session summaries are available online for those who cannot attendand for review for those present. These summaries aim to extract the key debates, dialogues, and learnings from each #MissionFinance session.

“The Great Debate: Can self-reporting ever be effective for investors?” featured compelling arguments from each side. Beginning with two-thirds of the audience voting in favour that it is, the debaters went on to explore the ways in which self-reporting might already be working—and might not be—as well as whether and how it might be improved. The final vote reflected a polarised audience, revealing the debaters had successfully changed people’s minds.

The panellists on the ‘for’ side were: Andreas Hoepner, Professor of Operational Risk, Banking & Finance, University College Dublin (UCD), Isabelle Laurent, Deputy Treasurer and Head of Funding, EBRD, and Hanna Waltsgott, Responsible Investment Analyst, Kempen Capital Management.

The panellists on the ‘against’ side were: Jakob Thoma, Managing Director, 2dii, Manuel Coeslier, Equity Portfolio Manager, MIROVA, and Dylan Tanner, Founder and Executive Director, InfluenceMap.

Laurent opened the discussion by illustrating how self-reporting is already effective: Four billion dollars have been raised to finance green assets in countries. Furthermore, transparency has been established as a core value of self-reporting.

Coeslier countered with the assertion that the most useful data is aggregated: “Even if we take climate change, even with the most known and used metrics, like carbon footprint, investors face different standards from different companies. For example, scope one and two and three. And, this data is reported with different assumptions therefore it’s impossible for the investor to aggregate the data in the right way.”

Waltsgott said investors already base many of their decisions on self-reported data, like financial statements, and that we can increase reliability and accuracy of data if:

  • Reporting is a requirement, according to sound standards that create comparability
  • It’s verified by an independent party
  • There are incentives to report accurate and reliable data out of self-interest

In his spirited response, Thoma pointed out that green bonds represent only one per cent of the total and they’re fraught with misuse and greenwashing. He said the conditions Waltsgott described will never be met, calling them a “pipe dream” and continued: “Self-reporting can be effective if unicorns fly through the sky.” Why? Because the data is two to three years old once it reaches an investor’s desk and because of granularity, making it impossible to compare it against other investments.

Hoepner walked the stage in an energised closing, claiming that ‘for’ is semantically contained within the debate question itself: “There’s an ‘ever’, it’s a how question.” He went on to explore what was needed for self-reporting to be effective, naming a change in incentives, that the data be verified by financially independent auditors, and that there be liability.

On the ‘against’ side, Tanner said, “The issue here is materiality. The opposition points out the conditions that need to be met for self-reporting to be effective but we’re nowhere close. We’ll have to rely on a ream of externals in a competitive market to reach what we’d like to achieve in the timeframe allowed.”

The final vote changed from its initial two thirds ‘for’ to ultimately favour the ‘against’ side, though it was extremely close.

The moderator, Professor Michael Mainelli, Director, Z/Yen, concluded, “Self-reporting is only a stepping stone to the future… If we get the economics right, corporates and behaviour will follow.”

He left the audience with a  final thought, a quote from The Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy:

“What we really need are rigidly defined areas of uncertainty and doubt.”

 
Location
Related Goal
Goal 11: Democratise climate risk information
Articles you may be interested in
In The News
Four EIT Climate-KIC innovators nominated for annual EIT Awards

The European Institute of Innovation and Technology (EIT) has released...

Four EIT Climate-KIC innovators nominated for annual EIT Awards
In Detail
Report offers recommendations for development of agricultural impact tool

A new report supported by EIT Climate-KIC’s CSA Booster programme proposes technical, governance and business arrangements for the development of a new tool for...

Report offers recommendations for development of agricultural impact tool
In Detail
Food value chains strategy report offers recommendations based on systemic i...

A new report details the work of EIT Climate-KIC and its partner Metabolic, a consulting company using systems thinking to tackle major sustainability challenges,...

Food value chains strategy report offers recommendations based on systemic impact
In The News
EIT Climate-KIC supports digital roadmap for a circular economy

EIT Climate-KIC, along with several European stakeholders, is advocating...

EIT Climate-KIC supports digital roadmap for a circular economy
In The News
EIT Climate-KIC urges London to lead in turning climate emergency into action

Climate innovation agency EIT Climate-KIC welcomed today the first...

EIT Climate-KIC urges London to lead in turning climate emergency into action
Opinion
London Climate Action Week: Climate Innovation Insights
London Climate Action Week: Climate Innovation Insights
Opinion
How can we deliver a net-zero emissions UK?
Andy Kerr Director, UK & Ireland, EIT Climate-KIC
How can we deliver a net-zero emissions UK?
Opinion
Can we identify the tipping points for transformative climate action?
Susannah Fisher Strategic Research Lead, EIT Climate-KIC
Can we identify the tipping points for transformative climate action?
In The News
Study launched on decarbonising Europe’s heavy industries by 2050

Industry representatives, regional experts, academics and EU officials held...

Study launched on decarbonising Europe’s heavy industries by 2050
In our community
Interview with Yvon Slingenberg of DG Climate Action, European Commission
Interview with Yvon Slingenberg of DG Climate Action, European Commission
In Detail
Evaluating the benefits of improved cooking solutions: impact data in high r...

Gold Standard today released a research study by Vivid Economics that estimates the economic value of Gold Standard-certified project benefits related to climate, health,...

Evaluating the benefits of improved cooking solutions: impact data in high resolution
In The News
New EIT Climate-KIC supported report proposes basis for a future EU taxonomy i...

The European Commission has welcomed the publication of the...

New EIT Climate-KIC supported report proposes basis for a future EU taxonomy in legislation
In The News
WCEF 2019: The challenges and potentials of circular procurement in cities

Increasing population growth and urbanisation intensifies the pressure on...

WCEF 2019: The challenges and potentials of circular procurement in cities
In The News
First round of 15 winners of Reinventing Cities competition announced

C40 Cities and EIT Climate-KIC have announced 15 winners...

First round of 15 winners of Reinventing Cities competition announced
In The News
Lisbon’s City Finance Lab-backed green participatory budget awarded €5 mil...

Lisbon City Council’s first-ever ‘green’ participatory budget, an initiative...

Lisbon’s City Finance Lab-backed green participatory budget awarded €5 million for next cycle
In The News
WCEF 2019: ‘The circular economy in cities’

EIT Climate-KIC CEO Kirsten Dunlop emphasised the importance of...

WCEF 2019: ‘The circular economy in cities’
In Detail
New Report on Circular Procurement in public construction projects shows how...

Public procurement affects a substantial share of world trade, amounting to more than €1.3 trillion per year. In the EU, the public purchase of...

New Report on Circular Procurement in public construction projects shows how targeted action can drive system-level impact
In The News
EIT Climate-KIC at World Circular Economy Forum 2019

EIT Climate-KIC is playing a prominent role at the...

EIT Climate-KIC at World Circular Economy Forum 2019
In The News
17 EIT Climate-KIC solutions included in MI 100 Global High Impact listing

13 EIT Climate-KIC Accelerator start-ups and four EIT Climate-KIC...

17 EIT Climate-KIC solutions included in MI 100 Global High Impact listing
In The News
EIT Climate-KIC’s global cleantech competition ClimateLaunchpad is open ...

EIT Climate-KIC’s ClimateLaunchpad, the world’s largest green business ideas...

EIT Climate-KIC’s global cleantech competition ClimateLaunchpad is open for registration
Opinion
Transformation Capital: A new investment logic for catalysing systems change
Dominic Hofstetter Transformation Capital, EIT Climate-KIC
Transformation Capital: A new investment logic for catalysing systems change
In The News
EIT Climate-KIC supported SkyNRG develops Europe’s first sustainable jet...

SkyNRG announced plans to develop Europe's first sustainable aviation...

EIT Climate-KIC supported SkyNRG develops Europe’s first sustainable jet fuel production plant
Opinion
Collaboration is hard!
Ulrike Linnig Innovation Lead, DACH, EIT Climate-KIC
Collaboration is hard!
In The News
EIT Climate-KIC supported report shows how to reduce industrial CO2 emissions

A new joint report, published by RWTH Aachen University...

EIT Climate-KIC supported report shows how to reduce industrial CO2 emissions
In The News
London event showcases innovation behind new investor climate tool

Yesterday’s event, titled “Applying Climate Risk Data to Investment...

London event showcases innovation behind new investor climate tool
In our community
Interview with Francisco de la Torre, Mayor of Malaga, Spain
Interview with Francisco de la Torre, Mayor of Malaga, Spain
Opinion
Adapting to climate change in Europe: Building a systemic and urgent vision
Susannah Fisher, EIT Climate-KIC and Andrew Norton, IIED
Adapting to climate change in Europe: Building a systemic and urgent vision
In our community
Interview with Andrzej Wiszniewski, President of the Board, National Energy ...
Interview with Andrzej Wiszniewski, President of the Board, National Energy Conservation Agency Poland
In The News
FEED-X programme aims to transform global feed industry

Supported by EIT Climate-KIC, global feed supplier Skretting, WWF...

FEED-X programme aims to transform global feed industry
In The News
New reports say net-zero emission EU heavy industry by 2050 is achievable

Achieving net-zero emissions by 2050 for European energy-intensive industries...

New reports say net-zero emission EU heavy industry by 2050 is achievable