Can self-reporting be effective for investors?

Most climate and ESG data is self-reported – can this approach ever provide investors with the reliable and comparable data they need to make the best investment decisions?

Self-reported data makes up a lion’s share of the climate and sustainability information available to investors but is often lacking in transparency and comparability. Data is crucial for investors to make responsible, long-term decisions so if corporate data is inconsistent it could hold back the huge levels of investment needed in sustainable solutions to limit climate change.

Data availability and accessibility also play key roles in triggering innovations that can help transform financial markets to align with global climate goals. EIT Climate KIC’s Climate Innovation Summit in Dublin on 6 November saw a group of experts including Andreas Hoepner and Jakob Thoma debate whether self-reporting can ever succeed in providing sufficient information to investors.

Opinion: Self-reporting can be effective

Andreas Hoepner & Fabiola Schneider, University College Dublin

We argue it is possible for self-reporting to be effective and sufficient for investors, but currently less than 2 per cent of companies report 100 per cent of their Scope 1 greenhouse gas emissions. Average disclosure is far below 95 per cent. So, more work needs to be done and we need more accuracy and simplicity in sustainability reporting.

But we think the fact that 20 companies are reporting all their emissions – or providing a quantitative statement of completeness showing how much they are collecting and reporting on if it’s not 100 per cent – shows that it is actually possible to provide effective and sufficient data for investors through self-reporting.

The quantitative statement of completeness is important. If a company can collect GHG data for 92 per cent of its revenues it’s better for it to say that than pretend it has collected everything. We need quantitative statements of disclosure in percentage terms – this data point is called Percentage of Disclosure or ES074 in Bloomberg’s environmental disclosure score – not just text in footnotes. We can’t build benchmarks on text only.

Investor demand for more clarity on ESG and sustainability is growing, and this should be a driver for companies to provide this type of clarity on emissions data. For example, we’ve seen recently the Church of England Pension Fund and Swedish AP7 pension fund challenge some companies they think might not be transparent enough in their sustainability reporting and disclosures of lobbying activities. So investors clearly do care about sustainability reporting and corporations putting their lobbying money where the mouth is.

We need also more education – some companies want to report 100 per cent of their emissions but don’t realise how hard it is. There needs to be transparency between company managers and people on the ground collecting sustainability data. Senior executives need to be trained in how hard it is to measure all of your emissions. They should then understand it requires budgets and technical expertise.

Opinion: Self-reporting isn’t effective

Jakob Thoma, 2 Degrees Investing Initiative

There are a few issues with self-reporting mechanisms, one being that the data is often presented in a way that’s not right for investors. Financial markets are moving into real-time data and big data, but traditional financial reporting channels are quarterly and sustainability reports are often published yearly. If, for example, your sustainability data from the 2017-18 financial year is published in, say, April or May 2019 – how relevant is that information to investors? Since the reports are issued so infrequently, they become static.

Granularity is also an issue. If you think about climate policies, you want to understand, for example, where all the power plants of a company are. If companies only report that global RE investment reached a certain level in the year, it’s not the kind of granularity you need as an investor to get an idea of how the company is aligned with regional science-based targets and how it is exposed to regional transition risks.

Another issue is that sustainability reporting in almost all cases revolve around performance indicators such as the number of jobs created or estimated avoided emissions. But everything that’s modelled internally won’t be comparable across companies. You can just change discount rates and then suddenly you have a different results. None of this will be comparable unless everyone uses the same model, which is very unrealistic to expect. I think it’s very unlikely that we’ll ever have a market standard or model used by all companies in the world– and indeed it is unclear that from a company management perspective this is even desirable.

I’m not saying you can’t draw any information from self-reported sustainability data, of course you can, in the same way you can draw information from an annual report. But self-reporting will play a second fiddle role. I think the data investors need will be made transparent in non-traditional financial reporting channels such as social media, regulatory reports and asset-based data. ESG data providers do some of this work already and this is the type of data that will inform investment decisions. 

This article is part of an eight-part series by Climate-KIC and Environmental Finance discussing Mission Finance, the theme of the 2018 Climate Innovation Summit in Dublin on 6 – 8th November.  To see the series hub click here.

 
Location
Ireland
Related Goal
Goal 10: Mainstream climate in financial markets
Articles you may be interested in
In The News
First European cluster accelerator programme launched in Frankfurt

How to take clusters to the next level and...

First European cluster accelerator programme launched in Frankfurt
Innovation Spotlight
Ioncell’s fiber innovation could help drive the circular economy transitio...

The textile, garment and fashion industries generate tonnes of pollution each year and recycle very little, which...

Ioncell’s fiber innovation could help drive the circular economy transition
Opinion
The challenge of redesigning venture capital
Dominic Hofstetter Transformation Capital, EIT Climate-KIC
The challenge of redesigning venture capital
In Detail
Clean and Healthy Construction

Insights from the C40 World Mayors Summit in Copenhagen: Master Class and Market Dialogue for Clean and Healthy Construction. Why clean construction? Kevin Austin,...

Clean and Healthy Construction
Opinion
If we have figured out transformation, why is the world still in such a mess?
Susannah Fisher Research, EIT-Climate-KIC
If we have figured out transformation, why is the world still in such a mess?
Opinion
The tyranny of categorisation
Dominic Hofstetter Transformation Capital, EIT Climate-KIC
The tyranny of categorisation
Opinion
EIT Climate-KIC strengthens biodiversity through systems change
Felicity Spors Head of International Affairs, EIT Climate-KIC
EIT Climate-KIC strengthens biodiversity through systems change
Opinion
Why our cities must act as beacons for ambitious climate action
Tom Mitchell Chief Strategy Officer, EIT Climate-KIC
Why our cities must act as beacons for ambitious climate action
In The News
Biggest-ever global hackathon to tackle climate breakdown

Over 100 Climathon events around the world turn grassroots...

Biggest-ever global hackathon to tackle climate breakdown
In The News
Global call for transformative solutions to tackle the climate emergency

EIT Climate-KIC launches Climathon Global Awards and Healthy, Clean...

Global call for transformative solutions to tackle the climate emergency
In The News
EIT Climate-KIC supported crop insurance project acquired by world’s largest...

The insurance sector is well aware of the rising...

EIT Climate-KIC supported crop insurance project acquired by world’s largest re-insurer
In The News
EIT Climate-KIC innovators celebrated at 2019 EIT Awards

The European Institute of Innovation and Technology (EIT) has...

EIT Climate-KIC innovators celebrated at 2019 EIT Awards
Opinion
Part three: Climate action #NotinNewYork
Andy Kerr Director, UK & Ireland, EIT Climate-KIC
Part three: Climate action #NotinNewYork
In Detail
New EIT Climate-KIC supported report finds digital technologies can vastly a...

As part of the UN Climate Action Summit, the Global Enabling Sustainability Initiative (GeSI) and Deloitte launched a report today, supported by EIT Climate-KIC,...

New EIT Climate-KIC supported report finds digital technologies can vastly accelerate the SDGs
Opinion
Part two: Climate action #NotinNewYork
Andy Kerr Director, UK & Ireland, EIT Climate-KIC
Part two: Climate action #NotinNewYork
Opinion
Climate action #NotinNewYork
Andy Kerr Director, UK & Ireland, EIT Climate-KIC
Climate action #NotinNewYork
In The News
Circular Cars Initiative launched at United Nations Climate Action Summit

On the occasion of the United Nations Climate Action...

Circular Cars Initiative launched at United Nations Climate Action Summit
In The News
We’re closing for business in solidarity with #ClimateStrike

EIT Climate-KIC will close this Friday 20 September, the...

We’re closing for business in solidarity with #ClimateStrike
In The News
Open Innovation Call targeting air quality and urban heat island effect launch...

The City of Copenhagen’s department Resilient and Sustainable City Solutions within...

Open Innovation Call targeting air quality and urban heat island effect launched
In The News
EIT Climate-KIC cleantech start-up ZOLAR attracts 10 Million Euro Investment

The Berlin-based start-up Zolar raises a 10 million EUR...

EIT Climate-KIC cleantech start-up ZOLAR attracts 10 Million Euro Investment
In The News
Breaking down barriers to climate-finance: the City Finance Lab launches secon...

Competition for the five most innovative financing solutions for...

Breaking down barriers to climate-finance: the City Finance Lab launches second call for proposals
Opinion
Innovating in complexity: Systemic investing
Dominic Hofstetter Transformation Capital, EIT Climate-KIC
Innovating in complexity: Systemic investing
In The News
Climathon onboard ‘Sail to the COP’

On 2 October, 36 young climate change agents will...

Climathon onboard ‘Sail to the COP’
In The News
Research reveals surprising link between socio-economic indicators and sustain...

A new study by EIT Climate-KIC partner academic institutions...

Research reveals surprising link between socio-economic indicators and sustainability transition
Opinion
Transformation capital: A new investment logic for catalysing systems change
Dominic Hofstetter Transformation Capital, EIT Climate-KIC
Transformation capital: A new investment logic for catalysing systems change
Opinion
Innovating in complexity: From single-point solutions to directional systems innovation
Dominic Hofstetter TRANSFORMATION CAPITAL, EIT CLIMATE-KIC
Innovating in complexity: From single-point solutions to directional systems innovation
In The News
Four EIT Climate-KIC innovators nominated for annual EIT Awards

The European Institute of Innovation and Technology (EIT) has released...

Four EIT Climate-KIC innovators nominated for annual EIT Awards
In Detail
Report offers recommendations for development of agricultural impact tool

A new report supported by EIT Climate-KIC’s CSA Booster programme proposes technical, governance and business arrangements for the development of a new tool for...

Report offers recommendations for development of agricultural impact tool
In Detail
Food value chains strategy report offers recommendations based on systemic i...

A new report details the work of EIT Climate-KIC and its partner Metabolic, a consulting company using systems thinking to tackle major sustainability challenges,...

Food value chains strategy report offers recommendations based on systemic impact
In The News
EIT Climate-KIC supports digital roadmap for a circular economy

EIT Climate-KIC, along with several European stakeholders, is advocating...

EIT Climate-KIC supports digital roadmap for a circular economy