Can we identify the tipping points for transformative climate action?

Tipping points occur when a small change can lead to significant – potentially irreversible – shifts in the system as a whole. These changes can be positive, like when generating power from renewables becomes cheaper than using coal, or negative, like the feedback loops from melting permafrost.

At the European Climate Change Adaptation conference in Lisbon last month, I listened to researchers and practitioners from different disciplines discussing tipping points around climate change. Just a few weeks later, others were gathered in Bonn discussing transformational change for climate finance. This left me wondering, when is it useful to think about tipping points in social systems? What does it add to our understanding and our ability to work towards faster and more transformative climate action?

In the world of climate science, the concept of tipping points and tipping cascades are well established. The concept of tipping cascades, described as a ‘Hothouse‘ or ‘Uninhabitable Earth‘, have captured the media’s imagination.

These tipping points are points in the physical system where a small change in one dimension of the system could lead to cascades of impacts across related systems. For example, tipping points or cascades at temperature increases of around 1-3 degrees are likely to lead to changes such as the melting of the Greenland ice sheet, melting of alpine glaciers and destruction of coral reefs. If global temperatures go beyond these points other systemic shifts could occur in the Indian monsoon, the climate of the Sahel and the jet stream. There are feedback mechanisms and loops that either support maintaining the planet in its current state (such as carbon uptake by land and oceans) or amplify a change and transition (such as forest diebacks).

So, within physical science the concept of tipping points is clear. They are triggers to be avoided as they may set off unexpected consequences and lead to sudden and irreversible shifts in the planetary system. Being aware of them means we are – in theory – more sensitised to the need to halt emissions before they are hit. Scientists and policymakers can take into account non-linear feedback loops that might start to trigger cascades of change when thinking about future scenarios.

Within social systems, however, tipping points can be thought of in many different ways.

Within work on the economic costs of adaptation, socio-economic tipping points can refer to the points where climate change may suddenly negatively alter the functioning of social systems. For example, flood risks could become uninsurable as climate risks escalate, critical infrastructure could fail and industries such as ski or coastal resorts could shut down. These triggers might lead to massively increased costs and the social system may have to fundamentally shift its way of working. This way of thinking about social tipping points echoes the way physical tipping points can be seen as a pinch point in the system to be avoided and planned for.

But some groups are also starting to think about positive tipping points. These are points that trigger the sudden change in individuals and in collective systems needed to transform society into a climate resilient low carbon one. These tipping points need transformative capacities in individuals and groups to make them happen and there are unlikely to be single points that can transform entire systems: it’s more likely that there are multiple positive tipping points around a range of solutions that need to be activated together to shift whole systems.

Others have also tried applying complex adaptive system thinking to explore whether there are precursors to changing from one state to another (whether positive or negative) that can be identified. These could be signals such as a critical slowdown in the old system, or measurable changes in the qualities of social systems or networks that make social tipping points more likely. Others are working on how transitions in a particular direction might be politically accelerated.

These points are of particular interest to us at EIT Climate-KIC as we are seeking to use innovation to trigger systemic change. As we move into implementing our new strategy we are co-designing a new way of working through our deep demonstrations. This involves working in a demand-led way with local decision-makers and linking the supply of innovation with demand for new solutions to trigger widespread societal shifts. We’re also working on building transformative capacities for change.

As we do this, we are asking ourselves how we will know whether we are on a pathway to transformative change. What concepts and theories will help us to learn from and improve our approach over time to keep on track? How might we best work with our partners to put in place the conditions that support these systemic changes?

One of the challenges in identifying positive social tipping points is how we model social systems to predict what the future might bring and what value such a theoretical prediction has in the messy real world.

Social scientists can analyse the past to explore how and why specific changes happened in certain contexts. But it’s easier to do it in hindsight. It’s much harder to do this analysis before the change happened and to predict the complex changes across social systems that can result from a specific event, technology or social change. The wave of protests by the school strikers and Extinction Rebellion were not widely predicted for example. Nor do we know whether these are a positive and long-lasting positive tipping point in public opinion or just a temporary blip of concern before we go back to business as usual.

Another challenge is choosing which theoretical lens best supports our approach. Many social theories can help us understand key factors underpinning societal shifts or suggest how processes might unfold. But these frameworks put varying emphasis on individuals, networks, organisations and wider contexts and structures, as well the role of technology, power and politics in supporting change. Some may apply more in some contexts than in others. Some may take much longer to lead to change than others. Some may support disruptive change, others incremental.

We don’t have the answers. We’re working through these ideas in practice through our experiments at EIT Climate-KIC and developing our research, knowledge networks and thinking as we go. We hope identifying potential positive tipping points will help us orientate the portfolio of experiments. Learning fast and moving on should help us refine our best guess of where systemic change might happen. We are sharing this thinking as it emerges to help us pool learning from across our network and beyond to support each other in the race to keep warming within 1.5 degrees.

We’d love to hear from you if you’re working on similar challenges and can share your experience or thinking.

 
Location
Portugal
Articles you may be interested in
In Detail
New report: Is Germany ready for the future?

E3G´s new report “Is Germany ready for the future? The case for action in a climate-changed world.”, supported by EIT Climate-KIC, finds that Germany...

New report: Is Germany ready for the future?
Opinion
Redesigning venture capital (part II): A blueprint
Dominic Hofstetter Transformation Capital, EIT Climate-KIC
Redesigning venture capital (part II): A blueprint
In The News
EIT Climate-KIC’s work in Slovenia

Last November, the Slovenian parliament passed a motion to...

EIT Climate-KIC’s work in Slovenia
In The News
Slovenia adopts EIT Climate-KIC Circular, Regenerative Economies Deep Demonstr...

The Slovenian parliament passed a motion to adopt an...

Slovenia adopts EIT Climate-KIC Circular, Regenerative Economies Deep Demonstration
In our community
Cities in a 1.5 degree world: What is there to learn from Leuven?
Cities in a 1.5 degree world: What is there to learn from Leuven?
In our community
Slovenia adopts EIT Climate-KIC circular economy proposal: Q&A with Kirs...
Slovenia adopts EIT Climate-KIC circular economy proposal: Q&A with Kirsten Dunlop
Innovation Spotlight
Elemental Water Makers’ solar desalination an asset as climate change ...

EIT Climate-KIC supported Elemental Water Makers is a water desalination scale-up that’s transforming water systems by enabling...

Elemental Water Makers’ solar desalination an asset as climate change threatens clean water
Innovation Spotlight
Zolar’s household solar kit is democratising the energy sector

Energy production and consumption are the largest sources of greenhouse gas emissions in the European Union, accounting for 80 per cent...

Zolar’s household solar kit is democratising the energy sector
In our community
Interview with policy and governance innovation experts at Madrid and Basque...
Interview with policy and governance innovation experts at Madrid and Basque Country Universities
In The News
COP25: Measurement and attribution of climate contribution to financiers

With the carbon costs of travel in mind, key...

COP25: Measurement and attribution of climate contribution to financiers
In The News
COP25: Madrid city side event

With the carbon costs of travel in mind, key...

COP25: Madrid city side event
In our community
Interview about Futures Literacy with Riel Miller, Head of Foresight at UNES...
Interview about Futures Literacy with Riel Miller, Head of Foresight at UNESCO
In The News
COP25: Climate leader insights

With the carbon costs of travel in mind, key...

COP25: Climate leader insights
In The News
OpenSurface land-use tracking platform launches at COP25

Pioneering AI, satellite and ground-sourced data technology drives more...

OpenSurface land-use tracking platform launches at COP25
In The News
COP25: Towards the systemic transformation

With the carbon costs of travel in mind, key...

COP25: Towards the systemic transformation
In The News
Helsinki launches Climate Watch to track city’s emission reductions

The City of Helsinki recently launched the ‘Climate Watch’,...

Helsinki launches Climate Watch to track city’s emission reductions
Opinion
Moments matter*
Michelle Zucker Director, Community Activation, EIT Climate-KIC
Moments matter*
In The News
Naked Energy secures €6.17 million in funding

Naked Energy, an EIT Climate-KIC supported solar energy startup...

Naked Energy secures €6.17 million in funding
In The News
First European cluster accelerator programme launched in Frankfurt

How to take clusters to the next level and...

First European cluster accelerator programme launched in Frankfurt
Innovation Spotlight
Ioncell’s fiber innovation could help drive the circular economy transitio...

The textile, garment and fashion industries generate tonnes of pollution each year and recycle very little, which...

Ioncell’s fiber innovation could help drive the circular economy transition
Opinion
The challenge of redesigning venture capital
Dominic Hofstetter Transformation Capital, EIT Climate-KIC
The challenge of redesigning venture capital
In Detail
Clean and Healthy Construction

Insights from the C40 World Mayors Summit in Copenhagen: Master Class and Market Dialogue for Clean and Healthy Construction. Why clean construction? Kevin Austin,...

Clean and Healthy Construction
Opinion
If we have figured out transformation, why is the world still in such a mess?
Susannah Fisher Research, EIT-Climate-KIC
If we have figured out transformation, why is the world still in such a mess?
Opinion
The tyranny of categorisation
Dominic Hofstetter Transformation Capital, EIT Climate-KIC
The tyranny of categorisation
Opinion
EIT Climate-KIC strengthens biodiversity through systems change
Felicity Spors Head of International Affairs, EIT Climate-KIC
EIT Climate-KIC strengthens biodiversity through systems change
Opinion
Why our cities must act as beacons for ambitious climate action
Tom Mitchell Chief Strategy Officer, EIT Climate-KIC
Why our cities must act as beacons for ambitious climate action
In The News
Biggest-ever global hackathon to tackle climate breakdown

Over 100 Climathon events around the world turn grassroots...

Biggest-ever global hackathon to tackle climate breakdown
In The News
Global call for transformative solutions to tackle the climate emergency

EIT Climate-KIC launches Climathon Global Awards and Healthy, Clean...

Global call for transformative solutions to tackle the climate emergency
In The News
EIT Climate-KIC supported crop insurance project acquired by world’s largest...

The insurance sector is well aware of the rising...

EIT Climate-KIC supported crop insurance project acquired by world’s largest re-insurer
In The News
EIT Climate-KIC innovators celebrated at 2019 EIT Awards

The European Institute of Innovation and Technology (EIT) has...

EIT Climate-KIC innovators celebrated at 2019 EIT Awards