The power of persuasion: Great Debate changes audience’s mind on self-reporting

With the carbon costs of travel in mind, Climate Innovation Summit session summaries are available online for those who cannot attendand for review for those present. These summaries aim to extract the key debates, dialogues, and learnings from each #MissionFinance session.

“The Great Debate: Can self-reporting ever be effective for investors?” featured compelling arguments from each side. Beginning with two-thirds of the audience voting in favour that it is, the debaters went on to explore the ways in which self-reporting might already be working—and might not be—as well as whether and how it might be improved. The final vote reflected a polarised audience, revealing the debaters had successfully changed people’s minds.

The panellists on the ‘for’ side were: Andreas Hoepner, Professor of Operational Risk, Banking & Finance, University College Dublin (UCD), Isabelle Laurent, Deputy Treasurer and Head of Funding, EBRD, and Hanna Waltsgott, Responsible Investment Analyst, Kempen Capital Management.

The panellists on the ‘against’ side were: Jakob Thoma, Managing Director, 2dii, Manuel Coeslier, Equity Portfolio Manager, MIROVA, and Dylan Tanner, Founder and Executive Director, InfluenceMap.

Laurent opened the discussion by illustrating how self-reporting is already effective: Four billion dollars have been raised to finance green assets in countries. Furthermore, transparency has been established as a core value of self-reporting.

Coeslier countered with the assertion that the most useful data is aggregated: “Even if we take climate change, even with the most known and used metrics, like carbon footprint, investors face different standards from different companies. For example, scope one and two and three. And, this data is reported with different assumptions therefore it’s impossible for the investor to aggregate the data in the right way.”

Waltsgott said investors already base many of their decisions on self-reported data, like financial statements, and that we can increase reliability and accuracy of data if:

  • Reporting is a requirement, according to sound standards that create comparability
  • It’s verified by an independent party
  • There are incentives to report accurate and reliable data out of self-interest

In his spirited response, Thoma pointed out that green bonds represent only one per cent of the total and they’re fraught with misuse and greenwashing. He said the conditions Waltsgott described will never be met, calling them a “pipe dream” and continued: “Self-reporting can be effective if unicorns fly through the sky.” Why? Because the data is two to three years old once it reaches an investor’s desk and because of granularity, making it impossible to compare it against other investments.

Hoepner walked the stage in an energised closing, claiming that ‘for’ is semantically contained within the debate question itself: “There’s an ‘ever’, it’s a how question.” He went on to explore what was needed for self-reporting to be effective, naming a change in incentives, that the data be verified by financially independent auditors, and that there be liability.

On the ‘against’ side, Tanner said, “The issue here is materiality. The opposition points out the conditions that need to be met for self-reporting to be effective but we’re nowhere close. We’ll have to rely on a ream of externals in a competitive market to reach what we’d like to achieve in the timeframe allowed.”

The final vote changed from its initial two thirds ‘for’ to ultimately favour the ‘against’ side, though it was extremely close.

The moderator, Professor Michael Mainelli, Director, Z/Yen, concluded, “Self-reporting is only a stepping stone to the future… If we get the economics right, corporates and behaviour will follow.”

He left the audience with a  final thought, a quote from The Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy:

“What we really need are rigidly defined areas of uncertainty and doubt.”

 
Location
Related Goal
Goal 11: Democratise climate risk information
Articles you may be interested in
In The News
Anders Wijkman represents EIT Climate-KIC at the International Society for the...

Speaking online at the inaugural Conference of IS4CE—the International...

Anders Wijkman represents EIT Climate-KIC at the International Society for the Circular Economy Conference
In The News
Vienna’s journey to carbon neutrality

EIT Climate-KIC is working with the city of Vienna...

Vienna’s journey to carbon neutrality
In The News
EIT Climate-KIC receives €8.4 million for innovation projects that stimulate...

Eleven climate innovation projects across Europe tackling COVID-19 related...

EIT Climate-KIC receives €8.4 million for innovation projects that stimulate job creation and support a post COVID-19 green recovery
In The News
CEO Kirsten Dunlop represents EIT Climate-KIC at Climate Policy Forum

On 25 June, EIT Climate-KIC attended the Climate Policy...

CEO Kirsten Dunlop represents EIT Climate-KIC at Climate Policy Forum
In Detail
A net zero future offers significant opportunities for the European economy,...

EIT Climate-KIC’s views on the EU 2030 Climate Target Plan.  The recent announcements from the European Commission on the EU Recovery Plan from the...

A net zero future offers significant opportunities for the European economy, society and citizens
In The News
EIT Climate-KIC supported LOOP-Ports project wins prestigious sustainability a...

The LOOP-Ports project, led by the Fundación Valenciaport  and funded by EIT Climate-KIC,...

EIT Climate-KIC supported LOOP-Ports project wins prestigious sustainability award
In The News
EIT Climate KIC joins roundtable as Republic of Korea moves Green Deal forward

On 24 June, EIT Climate-KIC attended the 7th Green...

EIT Climate KIC joins roundtable as Republic of Korea moves Green Deal forward
In our community
Water scarcity in Southern Europe: Manufacturing expert insights
Water scarcity in Southern Europe: Manufacturing expert insights
Opinion
A scientist’s opinion: Interview with Cliona Howie Del Rio about systems thinking
A scientist’s opinion: Interview with Cliona Howie Del Rio about systems thinking
In Detail
Citizen activation is essential for Europe to meet its climate ambition

EIT Climate-KIC provides ideas for action under the European Climate Pact. The debate on how to achieve ambitious climate targets is often dominated by...

Citizen activation is essential for Europe to meet its climate ambition
In The News
EIT Climate-KIC shines at the GLF Bonn Digital Conference, the year’s la...

EIT Climate-KIC’s Director of Sustainable Land Use and member...

EIT Climate-KIC shines at the GLF Bonn Digital Conference, the year’s largest global digital conference on the environment
In The News
EIT Climate-KIC supported Accelerator Cities commits to boosting the rate of U...

The UK Green Building Council (UKGBC) has entered a...

EIT Climate-KIC supported Accelerator Cities commits to boosting the rate of UK home retrofits
In The News
EIT Climate-KIC supported Climeworks raises over €67 million to expand its c...

Climeworks, the world leader in capturing CO2 from air,...

EIT Climate-KIC supported Climeworks raises over €67 million to expand its carbon dioxide removal capacities
In The News
EIT Climate-KIC supported Zeleros raises €7 million for the development of h...

EIT Climate-KIC supported Zeleros Hyperloop has completed a financing...

EIT Climate-KIC supported Zeleros raises €7 million for the development of hyperloop in Europe
In our community
A just transformation for Rugeley, as the power station comes down
A just transformation for Rugeley, as the power station comes down
In Detail
Challenging paradigms as the gateway to innovation: New IIPP report for EIT ...

EIT Climate-KIC partner the UCL Institute for Innovation and Public Purpose (IIPP), which works on changing how public value is imagined, practiced and evaluated...

Challenging paradigms as the gateway to innovation: New IIPP report for EIT Climate-KIC’s Landscapes as Carbon Sinks Deep Demonstration
In our community
Water scarcity in Southern Europe: Raw materials expert insights
Water scarcity in Southern Europe: Raw materials expert insights
In Detail
Challenge-led system mapping: A knowledge management approach

The challenge-led system mapping approach responds to the need to improve the practitioner’s capacity to move towards system change by providing mechanisms by which...

Challenge-led system mapping: A knowledge management approach
In The News
EIT Climate-KIC is restructuring to deliver systems transformation for climate...

EIT Climate-KIC is restructuring to provide “systems transformation as...

EIT Climate-KIC is restructuring to deliver systems transformation for climate change
In our community
Water scarcity in Southern Europe: Food expert insights
Water scarcity in Southern Europe: Food expert insights
In The News
EIT Climate-KIC and partners reassess our values in the ‘new normal’

EIT Climate-KIC, together with Edgeryders, ETH Zurich and IOTA,...

EIT Climate-KIC and partners reassess our values in the ‘new normal’
In our community
Water scarcity in Southern Europe: Climate expert insights
Water scarcity in Southern Europe: Climate expert insights
Opinion
Who’s doing what: A news round-up of selected COVID-19 responses and recovery plans
Felicity Spors Head of International Affairs, EIT Climate-KIC
Who’s doing what: A news round-up of selected COVID-19 responses and recovery plans
In The News
Co-Action carbon capture project opens new field plots

Yesterday, EIT Climate-KIC community member ‘Co-Action,’ a carbon capture...

Co-Action carbon capture project opens new field plots
In Detail
Implications of the COVID-19 pandemic for global sustainable finance: An int...

The UN Environment convened Financial Centres for Sustainability (FC4S) recently published a working paper, supported by EIT Climate-KIC, on the implications of the COVID-19...

Implications of the COVID-19 pandemic for global sustainable finance: An internal framework for response strategies
In Detail
A cartoonathon: Using humour to drive insights

Last week, in an event supported by EIT Climate-KIC, over 150 participants from more than 60 countries took part in a virtual ‘cartoonathon’ to...

A cartoonathon: Using humour to drive insights
In The News
EIT Climate-KIC launches Call for Proposals to support post-COVID-19 green rec...

EIT Climate-KIC’s ‘Extraordinary Post COVID-19 Regeneration Call 2020’ will...

EIT Climate-KIC launches Call for Proposals to support post-COVID-19 green recovery
Opinion
COVID-19 responses and recovery plans—the good news and the bad news
Felicity Spors Head of International Affairs, EIT Climate-KIC
COVID-19 responses and recovery plans—the good news and the bad news
Innovation Spotlight
How to engage citizens in a just transformation process

With climate change, we are facing one of the biggest challenges of our lifetime – one that...

How to engage citizens in a just transformation process
In The News
The European Union has the tools to boost a sustainable recovery from the COVI...

In a statement released today, the Technical Expert Group...

The European Union has the tools to boost a sustainable recovery from the COVID-19 pandemic, say TEG experts